You do not decide this, and that is worth saying first. You should never try to do this yourself. A provider, such as a podiatrist, will need to do this to make sure the debridement is done correctly and does not make the injury worse. What you can do is notice the thing that prompts the decision, and report it.
What prompts it is dead tissue. Debridement is done to remove devitalized (dead) tissue, such as necrotic tissue, slough, bioburden, biofilm, and dying cells. In practice, that is the covering you can sometimes see: dead skin that is yellow, tan, green, or brown, or black edges, which are a sign of dead tissue.
The reason it can’t simply be left is specific. Dead tissue acts as a physical barrier to new skin growing across the wound. It prevents new blood vessels, granulation tissue and new skin from forming. It is also a source of nutrients for bacteria. Put simply, this tissue must be removed to help your wound heal.
There is a second reason, and it is the one most useful to you. Dead tissue hides the wound. It may prevent the clinician from accurately judging how big and how serious the wound is, and can even mask an infection underneath. A sore covered in dead skin is “unstageable” because its depth can’t be judged. If nobody can see your wound bed, nobody can tell you how it is doing.
So the practical test is not whether the wound needs debriding. It is whether you can see the wound bed at all. If what you are looking at is a covering rather than a wound, say so, and say roughly how much of it is hidden.
One situation runs the other way, so do not assume dark means removal. Debridement is not done on dry and intact eschars with no clinical evidence of underlying infection. One example is an unstageable pressure ulcer with intact eschar at the sacrum, buttock or heel. Black can be a reason to leave it alone, which is exactly why the judgment is not yours.
