Can scar tissue break down and reopen?

Yes. Scar tissue is never as strong as the skin it replaced, so it can break down again, especially if the original cause, like pressure, swelling, or poor blood flow, comes back. A scar that keeps opening should be checked by a provider.

When a wound heals, the body fills the gap with scar tissue. Scar tissue is made mostly of a protein called collagen. In healthy skin, collagen is neatly organized. In a scar, it is never as well organized, and that makes the scar weaker.

Scar tissue does get stronger over time. The last stage of healing, called remodeling, starts around three weeks after the injury and can go on for up to a year. Even after that, a healed wound only reaches about 80% of the strength of the original skin. It never fully catches up.

Because scar tissue is weaker, it can break down if it is put under stress. Some of the things that can cause a healed wound to open again include:

The original cause coming back. If pressure, swelling from poor vein function, poor blood flow, or rubbing from shoes caused the first wound, the same thing can reopen it. For example, people who have had a venous leg ulcer are the most likely to get another one.

Injury to the area. A bump, scrape, or cut over a scar can open it more easily than normal skin.

Health conditions that slow healing, such as diabetes, poor circulation, nerve damage, poor nutrition, or smoking.

Wounds that were closed with a skin graft can also break down again. Ulcers coming back after grafting is not uncommon.

Rarely, a sore that keeps healing and reopening is not a simple scar problem. An open sore that heals and then comes back, or a firm, flat area that looks like a scar, can be a sign of basal cell carcinoma, a type of skin cancer. That’s one reason a scar that keeps breaking down should be looked at.

You can lower the chance of scar breakdown by protecting the area, keeping the skin moisturized, and continuing the steps that treat the original cause, such as pressure relief, compression stockings if your provider recommends them, or proper footwear.

What to watch for

Contact your provider if a scar or healed area becomes red, warm, swollen, blistered, or opens up, even a little.

Contact your provider if a sore heals and then keeps coming back in the same spot, or if a scar-like area is changing.

Contact your provider right away if a reopened scar shows signs of infection, such as pus, a bad smell, spreading redness, or fever.

Wound Wizard is general education and can’t examine your wound. If your scar has broken down, ask your provider what caused it and what can protect the area going forward.

What we look at

  • Examining the scar and the skin around it
  • Reviewing what caused the original wound and whether it is still present
  • Checking blood flow and swelling in the area
  • Reviewing footwear, compression, or pressure-relief needs
  • Considering a biopsy if a sore keeps healing and coming back

Sources

  1. Physiology, Wound Healing — StatPearls, NCBI Bookshelf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK535406/
  2. Venous leg ulcer - Prevention — NHS https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/leg-ulcer/prevention/
  3. Leg ulcers — DermNet https://dermnetnz.org/topics/leg-ulcer
  4. Wound care centers — MedlinePlus https://medlineplus.gov/ency/patientinstructions/000739.htm
  5. Signs and Symptoms of Basal Cell Carcinoma — American Cancer Society https://www.cancer.org/cancer/types/basal-and-squamous-cell-skin-cancer/detection-diagnosis-staging/signs-and-symptoms.html